Logo

050040040 Transfer Policy PDP WG - Shared screen with speaker view
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
36:21
Please review ICANN Expected Standards of Behavior here: https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/expected-standards-2016-06-28-en
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
36:30
Reminders:**Members: when using chat, please select Panelists and Attendees in order for everyone to see chat.
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
36:36
**Alternates not replacing a member are not permitted to engage in the chat or use any of the other zoom room functionalities such as raising hands or agreeing/disagreeing.
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
40:32
As a reminder only members and alternates replacing members on this call should vote.
Barbara Knight (RySG)
47:29
+1 Kristian
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
47:44
Yeah a very good point Kristian. I was planning to mark the losing Rr FOA as dependant on FOA also
Barbara Knight (RySG)
48:17
+1 Sarah
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
48:54
**Members: when using chat, please select Panelists and Attendees in order for everyone to see chat.
James Galvin (RySG)
49:22
repeating for all - +1 Kristian and Sarah
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
52:28
I think the topics listed are sufficient
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
53:30
so i'm marking q2 as "yes" because we said this is tied to the FOAs
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
53:36
wait
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
53:39
this is still the FOAs! i'm sorry
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
57:06
Is it a security measure relating to the registered domain itself or to the dns for that domain? Like, is it directly related to the transfer process?
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
57:11
**Members: when using chat, please select Panelists and Attendees in order for everyone to see chat.
Berry Cobb
57:32
Based on Jim's intervention, this could be an appropriate area for when we seek early input from the SOs/ACs. So starting to think about some questions that we can add here will be helpful.
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
57:57
I think if we're discussing this we'll need some education on how DNSSEC works, what the current method is to move the DNSSEC provider from one to another, how it ties to the transfer process, etc. before we can confirm if it's even in scope for this PDP
Steinar Grøtterød (At-Large)
59:30
+1 Sarah
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
59:55
I think first we must figure out if it's in scope for what we want to accomplish here. (I am not convinced that it is)
JW λ John Woodworth (ISPCP)
59:57
+1 Sarah
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:00:03
Kristian - right, which I think is out of scope here
Prudence Malinki(RrSG)
01:00:03
+1 Sarah
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:00:47
sure but if we're considering changing scope I would want to see a Very Good Reason for that
Berry Cobb
01:01:30
Absolutely agree.
Berry Cobb
01:01:49
not a 1st resort, but last.
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:05:21
Standards relating to authcode accessibility
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:06:13
Agree that those topics are connected
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:06:33
that could work, but maybe losing before gaining
Berry Cobb
01:07:50
Got it. Thanks Sarah.
Berry Cobb
01:08:56
Thanks for that dry run repeat of last weeks topics. Very helpful to me.
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:09:23
I thought this was great re pace etc
Berry Cobb
01:12:30
New territory here, so encourage members to speak up.
Andrea Glandon - ICANN Org
01:15:31
**Members: when using chat, please select Panelists and Attendees in order for everyone to see chat.
Emily Barabas - ICANN Org
01:17:45
Here is a link to the report: https://mm.icann.org/pipermail/council/attachments/20200219/94112f0f/Rec27-Wave1-Updated-14feb20-0001.pdf
Emily Barabas - ICANN Org
01:18:00
See item 5 and 9 on page 23-25
Emily Barabas - ICANN Org
01:18:26
As well as two items on FOA on page 28
Theo Geurts (RrSG)
01:25:43
Great, sounds good
Roger Carney (chair)
01:40:27
@Steve good distinctions that should be looked at
Sarah Wyld (RrSG)
01:41:40
Apologies if I'm misunderstanding (I had to step away) but I thought Steve referred to a situation where a law firm registers a domain on behalf of their client. I'm not sure that's something to even consider here? The law firm would be the registrant, nothing further to say. It may be a consideration for the PPSAI group.
Richard Merdinger (RrSG)
01:44:31
I agree that the different incarnations of having a private/proxied registration have different implications, with the one mentioned above probably being out of scope, but worthy of some discussion.
Kristian Ørmen (RrSG)
01:48:02
Thank you