00:33:59 Julie Bisland: Welcome to the IDN Scoping Team call on the Thursday, 12 December 2019 at 13:00 UTC. 00:39:36 Maxim Alzoba: we were talking about different TLDs 00:40:07 Dennis Tan: Same principle would apply at the top level…. provided that RZ-LGR is adopted 00:40:55 Dennis Tan: variants are not meant for transliteration or translation of a label (top or lower levels) 00:50:39 Maxim Alzoba: it was not representation process 00:50:52 Maxim Alzoba: so it was individual members 00:52:11 Dennis Tan: @Maxim, It was not a PDP or consensus policy development per se 00:52:54 Dennis Tan: Hence the desire to change this 00:53:29 Dennis Tan: @Maxim, I tend to agree .. public comments may not be sufficient to claim “consensus” 00:54:38 ariel.liang: @Maxim - do you mind clarifying which GNSO Council record you want Staff to identify? 00:55:39 Maxim Alzoba: @Ariel, the meeting with the reason for the deferral and the meetings where the IDN item was discussed in 2019 00:56:12 Maxim Alzoba: @Dennis it is in Operpating Procedures https://gnso.icann.org/sites/default/files/file/field-file-attach/op-procedures-24oct19-en.pdf 00:56:21 Maxim Alzoba: what makes the policy 00:57:07 ariel.liang: @Maxim - I believe it has been recorded on page 3 of the Options Paper: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1o_9bfnkKufrSxiJGxpNcOcfTK2VLWp5XYQvwe5qxJlc/edit#heading=h.4l14uuzc4nrt 00:57:27 ariel.liang: 3rd and 4th paragraphs 00:57:29 Maxim Alzoba: also it was discussed on one of the F2F meetings 01:03:29 Maxim Alzoba: potentially it requires IPC (TM owners) 01:05:57 Maxim Alzoba: it would be usefull to add those materials to avoid duplication of records 01:14:12 Dennis Tan: If variants tables are implemented post-registration, I would imagine that the registry operator will have the ability to grandfather those names 01:14:40 Maxim Alzoba: @Dennis, it is something required to be formalized 01:15:25 Dennis Tan: IDN G v4.0 allows for registry operator to establish their own policy 01:15:40 Maxim Alzoba: We were promised in the past that all IANA IDN tables to be grandfathered, which is not the case now 01:16:56 Dennis Tan: Right. This is a separate issue, though. At least in my mind. Staff is asking RySG to work on a resolution approach 01:17:09 Maxim Alzoba: I do not hear Edmon 01:17:16 Maxim Alzoba: now I hear 01:23:49 Maxim Alzoba: PDP WGs bound to their Charter and GNSO procedures 01:28:14 Steve Chan: i actually wanted to make a handful of other comments 01:33:26 Maxim Alzoba: next week is basically vacations 01:33:49 Maxim Alzoba: might not work for me 01:34:33 Maxim Alzoba: F2F in LA 01:34:52 Maxim Alzoba: in Jan 01:36:00 Maxim Alzoba: 10 days prior 01:36:01 Steve Chan: no problem 01:36:06 Maxim Alzoba: to the meeting 01:36:12 Maxim Alzoba: it is the last moment items are allowed in 01:36:24 Dennis Tan: No more comments 01:36:27 Dennis Tan: Thank you 01:36:31 Maxim Alzoba: 10 days before the GNSO meeting 01:36:41 Maxim Alzoba: see you in 2020 01:36:45 Maxim Alzoba: bye all 01:36:46 maarten.simon: bye 01:36:47 ariel.liang: happy holidays all