Logo

051040031: RySG Meetings - Shared screen with speaker view
Sue Schuler (RySG Secretariat)
22:11
Welcome to the meeting of the RA/RAA Amendment discussion Group. Please announce your name before speaking for purposes of the transcript. Please mute your microphone when not speaking to help maintain sound quality. Thanks
Russ Weinstein
22:26
Hi everyone, great to be here :)
Ashley Heineman
23:56
It's my first!
Jeffrey Neuman
24:14
First of many :)
Rubens Kuhl
33:55
2.5 years, then.
Rubens Kuhl
34:09
30 months
Rubens Kuhl
34:28
6+18, 24 months then.
Rubens Kuhl
45:56
IRT's can't change technical specifications, either IETF standards or the RDAP profile.
Jeffrey Neuman
53:08
Understand your concern, but I think in this case its apples to oranges. If there is a Consensus Policy, they we must come into compliance within a reasonable time period. That is already set forth in the agreements
Jeffrey Neuman
53:23
Temporary policies are just that...temporary
Rubens Kuhl
55:14
Most changes in EPDP Phase 1 make less information available in RDAP, not more. That's usually easier.
Donna Austin
01:00:32
Agree with Jeff.
Rubens Kuhl
01:06:38
2000 ms is the port-43 WHOIS SLR today.
Donna Austin
01:09:16
A valid response is that the technology is different.
Jody Kolker
01:22:15
@Karla - can you send out your spreadsheet to this group?
Owen Smigelski (Namecheap)
01:24:09
Web whois searches at Namecheap were less than .5% of all whois queries during the same time period that ICANN is citing.
Jeffrey Neuman
01:26:27
Its all of whack....look at the anomoliees
Jeffrey Neuman
01:27:45
But the use is not what you believe it is. Its not even close. Look at the anomolies
Jeffrey Neuman
01:29:05
And if registries have those high numbers, there is a problem with the registry's reporting
Russ Weinstein
01:30:44
Hi Jeff, ok we understand, The SSAC has raised similar concerns. We will have some discussions with specific registries.
Rubens Kuhl
01:31:53
BTW, all of all queries for our TLDs are from ICANN SLA Monitoring.
Rubens Kuhl
01:32:00
(our queries)
Jeffrey Neuman
01:34:07
I think the bottom line is that the assumption that searchability is really used is not necessarily correct. And if that is the assumption behind wanting all registries to implement some form of searchable RDAP, then the need for searchability is not correct
Rubens Kuhl
01:34:27
Just suggest a consensus policy that requires RDAP Search and you will get it.
Rubens Kuhl
01:42:09
1-2-3 Compliance process
Russ Weinstein
01:46:54
Ok, thanks
Rubens Kuhl
01:47:46
Summer ? No summer around here... ;-)
Catherine Merdinger
01:48:04
Thanks, everyone