Logo

Michelle DeSmyter's Personal Meeting Room - Shared screen with speaker view
Sue Schuler
18:27
Welcome to the meeting of the RA/RAA Amendment Discussion Group. Please announce your name before speaking for purposes of the transcript. Please mute your microphone when not speaking to help maintain sound quality. Thanks
Sue Schuler
18:42
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1iQ0QxIlOS_ObSyHdF0lguuZ_EYAa8-tU0iiiLaeH3eM/edit
Maxim Alzoba
26:20
rfc reference?
Maxim Alzoba
26:53
we might need a set of rdap rfcs we like
Maxim Alzoba
27:25
not all of rdap rfcs (so we do not mention those we do not like)
Maxim Alzoba
30:07
explanation of rdap via profile might lead to change of what rdap is for us to comply
Maxim Alzoba
30:17
with
Maxim Alzoba
31:11
it would be nice to have some certainty of content
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
31:19
revised is good
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
31:32
dated URL showing the revision ?
Maxim Alzoba
31:42
they add - each registry has to pay 1m usd a year
Maxim Alzoba
31:52
we do not need that
Maxim Alzoba
32:39
I am not sure it is a time to introduce an idea of document checksum and version ;) for references
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
35:39
I like that @Jim
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
36:45
Careful with that sentence, we need to agree on the tech spec and, yes Rick, what exists means
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
37:29
suitable?
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
37:37
when a suitable tech spec…
Maxim Alzoba
39:00
the reason to ask is that iana messed up a list of tlds. txt due to cdn providers
Maxim Alzoba
39:18
and it's checksum
Maxim Alzoba
39:59
they are currently trying to fix that, but it took months for them to recognize it as an issue
Maxim Alzoba
40:39
+1 , assign it all
Zoe Bonython
44:46
That was paraphrasing Jeff
Maxim Alzoba
49:04
in epdp1 policy there is a reference that we provide the sunset
Maxim Alzoba
49:27
I mean in the document recently sent
Maxim Alzoba
49:43
rec27 part
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
51:10
I agree @Rick
Maxim Alzoba
54:50
why don't we declare it, and be happy?
Maxim Alzoba
01:03:20
all registrars and registries use "whois sunset provided" as whois output
Donna Austin, Neustar
01:03:44
ICANN's concern is that the user will not be able to readily adapt to RDAP because they are used to WHOIS. There will be a transition period and I think we did agree that registrars could start to put in a note that future requests should be done through RDAP.
Maxim Alzoba
01:04:14
do we have to wait until all guys who know whois extinct?
Maxim Alzoba
01:04:38
why can't we just reditect?
Maxim Alzoba
01:04:52
from whois.nic.tld to our rdap?
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:06:53
@maxim - you can’t redirect because port 80 is not a replacement for port 43.
Maxim Alzoba
01:18:21
yea, provision of rdap on 43 port is too much
Zoe Bonython
01:19:38
RrSG have a membership meeting on 6 April (next Monday) and then not until 20 April
Zoe Bonython
01:19:53
So to discuss with our membership, ideally the doc will be ready by Friday
Zoe Bonython
01:20:17
but also discussion can happen on the list if it needs to
J.C. Vignes (Uniregistry)
01:21:56
Nope, great work today!
Donna Austin, Neustar
01:21:59
Thanks for driving Jim
Donna Austin, Neustar
01:22:03
sorry Rick
Catherine Merdinger
01:22:09
Thanks for everyone’s hard work!