Logo

051040031: RySG Meetings - Shared screen with speaker view
Sue Schuler (RySG Secretariat)
30:51
Welcome to the meeting of the RA/RAA Amendment Discussion Group. Please announce your name before speaking for purposes of the transcript. Please mute your microphone when not speaking to help maintain sound quality. Thanks
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
37:12
I think you have the top priorities right
Catherine Merdinger
37:36
I approve!
Sam Demetriou
37:39
I think that’s right
Sam Demetriou
42:34
yup, all good
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
42:37
Sounded like a good recap to me
Maxim Alzoba
42:39
I am not sure icann unbundle s anything at all
Jeffrey Neuman
44:07
I think they are using it as a bargaining chip
James Galvin (Afilias)
45:40
nodding
Maxim Alzoba
49:07
it was an attempt to glue RDAP to the policy
Maxim Alzoba
49:29
when Registries sent reconsideration request
James Galvin (Afilias)
51:04
ok.
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
51:16
need to drop now, bbl
Jeffrey Neuman
51:41
Hopefully we will spot that all in the development of the Consensus Policy itself
Maxim Alzoba
54:20
only those who does not rsep out
Maxim Alzoba
54:43
that is why we need someone rsep ing that out
Maxim Alzoba
55:24
can not, it is too late here
James Galvin (Afilias)
59:45
yes catherine
Ashley Heineman
01:00:38
I think we need a white board for this conversation...
Sam Demetriou
01:00:43
I think there’s a use case where a TLD that offers “searchable” queries could show the public RDDS info for other domains when you do a wildcard lookup?
Maxim Alzoba
01:00:50
no searchable port 43 was offered
Jeffrey Neuman
01:01:00
Ashley - this issue effects only the registries
Ashley Heineman
01:01:23
I'm not saying it effects registrars.
Sam Demetriou
01:01:37
Or if you offer search capabilities for something like name servers, it would reveal other domains with that name server bc that isn’t personal data and generally isn’t redacted
Ashley Heineman
01:01:59
Just a lot of folks talking about things and it isn't clear if any side is following the same logic.
Jeffrey Neuman
01:05:18
@Jim - But there is a legal definition of searchability in the agreements. It is different than your pure definition of search
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:08:36
+1 bet - i agree that having our own point of view is important.
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:08:54
it’s the need to have a legal argument that’s getting in the way. :-)
Maxim Alzoba
01:09:05
if search ability requires RSEP to turn it off then RDAP search ability requires RSEP to turn it on
Maxim Alzoba
01:10:57
we should not sacrifice contractual language to gain small time PR
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:15:13
we’re scheduled for 90 minutes. are we going to go the full 90 minutes?
Sam Demetriou
01:16:24
agree w Jeff on this one
Maxim Alzoba
01:16:36
any formal breach is a breach leading to termination
Maxim Alzoba
01:16:43
at the moment they like it
Maxim Alzoba
01:17:25
rdds is a critical function
Maxim Alzoba
01:17:39
without names of particular bits
Maxim Alzoba
01:18:00
it should be in the text of RA
Maxim Alzoba
01:18:16
the transition period mercy
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:18:46
So I'm reading this as an olive branch from ICANN. Is that how we're all reading this?
Maxim Alzoba
01:19:07
depends on how compliance reads it later
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:19:11
Thank you, Rick
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:20:10
I can hang for 30 more min now that I'm back from my client call.
Catherine Merdinger
01:20:13
I have time
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:20:18
i can go but would like the time back
Ashley Heineman
01:20:20
I'll need to drop.
Sam Demetriou
01:20:22
What if we all tried to wrap this up in 10?
Ashley Heineman
01:20:25
But I"m not critical
Jeffrey Neuman
01:20:30
I think 10 works
Sam Demetriou
01:20:32
I have faith in us, guys and gals
Maxim Alzoba
01:24:54
date
Sam Demetriou
01:27:14
Sorry, misstatement on my part - I mean there’s no SLA ramp-up
Sam Demetriou
01:27:39
Like, it’s not going to change after 6 months of operation. They want us at the permanent SLA out of the gate
Maxim Alzoba
01:29:57
+1
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:30:20
+1 rick
Catherine Merdinger
01:30:31
I agree - short term pain for long term gain
Catherine Merdinger
01:30:40
My evil twin
James Galvin (Afilias)
01:34:42
jamming - yes
Graeme Bunton (Tucows)
01:35:40
I mean, you've contributed more...
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:35:47
aww he would be proud
Catherine Merdinger
01:35:49
Damn right
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:35:59
hahaha zing Graeme!
Ashley Heineman
01:36:03
I'm telling!
Ashley Heineman
01:36:05
kidding...
Sam Demetriou
01:36:15
The Demetriou Doctrine: Ending everything 15 mins early
Catherine Merdinger
01:36:18
Like I’m not going to call him immediately after this meeting
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:36:28
baby Graeme!
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:36:31
love it
Jeffrey Neuman
01:36:32
The Hills are alive with the sound of Graeme
Catherine Merdinger
01:36:38
Can that be sent around to the list?
Brian King (MarkMonitor)
01:36:56
I screenshotted that for... purposes